What are the Pros and Cons of Municipal Landfills?

While municipal landfills have significant environmental drawbacks, they nonetheless deliver important benefits when managed properly. This entry discusses both sides of the issue. Q&As include:

1. Are municipal landfills really necessary?
2. What are some of the advantages of municipal landfills?
3. What is an example of a well-run municipal landfill?
4. What are some of the disadvantages of municipal landfills?
5. How can the benefits of municipal landfills be ensured and maximized?
6. Have questions about landfills?

1. Are municipal landfills really necessary?

Yes. Municipal landfills were conceived as a practical solution for disposing of large amounts of waste in a clean and organized manner. As with anything, some are better than others.

2. What are some of the advantages of municipal landfills?

Municipal landfills can reduce the risks of uncontrolled waste decomposition that might occur in illegal dumping sites, the latter of which would cause worse environmental harm. However, to mitigate their environmental impact, municipal landfills must be designed and operated for sustainability and subject to strict monitoring and management practices.

Specific advantages of municipal landfills include:

1. Energy Generation.

Modern municipal landfills are designed to capture methane gas that’s produced during waste decomposition, which can then be used as a renewable energy source. A notable example is the Altamont Landfill in California. It captures methane gas and uses it to power a renewable energy facility that feeds electricity into the local power grid, simultaneously reducing greenhouse gas emissions by preventing methane from escaping into the atmosphere.

The Altamont Landfill in California has received several awards and recognitions for its innovative practices and commitment to sustainability. Some notable awards include:

• California Waste Management Board Recognition—for its environmental compliance and proactive waste management strategies.
• SWANA Awards—for its excellence in solid waste management across various categories.
• Green Business Certification—for its efforts in sustainability and environmental stewardship.
• Community Engagement Awards—for its outreach programs and commitment to educating the community about waste management and sustainability.

2. Land Reclamation. Once they’re closed and capped, municipal landfills are often converted into parks or recreational areas, thus revitalizing previously unusable land. One example of a public park being created from a landfill is Freshkills Park in Staten Island, New York.

Freshkills was once the largest landfill in the world. It’s now a sprawling greenspace of meadows and wetlands that provides walking and biking trails, sports fields, and educational facilities to the surrounding community, all while restoring the landscape and providing habitat for wildlife.

3. Resource Recovery. Many municipal landfills reduce the overall volume of waste that goes into the ground by incorporating technologies that recover recyclable materials or compost organic waste.

A notable example is the Cleveland Materials Recovery Facility in Ohio, which is capable of processing 144K tons of detritus per year. It uses advanced technologies to sort metals, plastics, paper, and other materials so they can be sent to recycling markets, thereby significantly reducing the amount of waste that ends up in the landfill.

3. What is an example of a well-run municipal landfill?

An example of a well-run municipal landfill is the Pine View Landfill in Bergen County, New Jersey. Here are some key features that contribute to its reputation:

• Comprehensive Recycling Programs. To minimize landfill use, Pine View implements effective waste diversion strategies, including recycling and composting initiatives.
• Advanced Environmental Controls. These sophisticated systems help mitigate environmental impact for leachate and gases.
• Sustainability Practices. Landfill managers foster better waste management practices by providing community education about waste reduction and sustainability.
• Regulatory Compliance. Pine View Landfill meets or exceeds state and federal environmental standards.

4. What are some of the disadvantages of municipal landfills?

Municipal landfills can pose several environmental dangers, including:

1. Soil and Water Contamination.

Leachate is a toxic liquid that forms when waste breaks down. It can seep into the ground and contaminate soil and groundwater, including drinking water sources.

A notorious example is Love Canal. In 1892, businessman William T. Love proposed a canal to connect parts of the Niagara River in New York state. Never finished, it left a deep ditch. Trouble started in the 1920s when the ditch became the city dump. Then, in the 1940s, the ditch was purchased by a chemical company that used it to dump about 20,000 tons of detritus from manufacturing dyes, perfumes, and solvents. Nearby residents’ longstanding health issues include high white blood‑cell counts and leukemia.

The Love Canal case prompted significant environmental reform, including the establishment of the Superfund program to clean up hazardous waste sites (see source). It remains a powerful reminder of the dangers associated with municipal landfills.

2. Greenhouse Gas Emissions.

Decomposing organic waste produces methane, which is a potent greenhouse gas. Perhaps ironically, the Freshkills Landfill on Staten Island, cited in Q.2 as a paradigm of land reclamation, nonetheless remains one of the most notorious landfills in the U.S. for greenhouse gas emissions, particularly methane. The history of Freshkills highlights the substantial greenhouse gas emissions associated with large landfills and the importance of effective waste management practices.

3. Air Pollution.

Along with other pollutants, municipal landfills can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) into the air, which can harm human health and contribute to smog formation.

The Pittsburgh’s Hazelwood Landfill in Pennsylvania is notorious for air pollution issues, being associated with various environmental problems, particularly because it’s near residential areas.

In the 1980s and 1990s, residents reported health issues and unpleasant odors linked to the landfill, which contained hazardous waste and generated air pollutants. The site has undergone various cleanup efforts, but its history of pollution and health concerns makes it a significant example of the dangers of poorly managed landfills.

4. Loss of Biodiversity.

Landfills can disrupt local ecosystems, leading to habitat destruction and loss of biodiversity. The Cleveland Landfill (aka, the Cleveland Dumpsite), is a notable example, notorious for its environmental impact on the surrounding areas, including the nearby Cuyahoga River.

When it was active, the Cleveland Landfill contributed to a decline in local wildlife populations by polluting and destroying habitat. Waste and contaminants affected soil and water quality, harming native species, and disrupting local ecosystems.

5. Pests and Vermin.

Landfills can attract rats, insects, and other pests that can spread diseases. The presence of organic waste creates favorable conditions for such vermin, leading to concerns about public health and sanitation for nearby communities.

The Cook County Landfill in Chicago is an instructive example, as it faces significant challenges with rodents, seagulls, and other scavengers due to its size and the types of waste deposited. Management practices have aimed to control pest populations, but the ongoing challenges illustrate the issues many landfills face regarding vermin.

6. Odor Issues.

Decomposing waste can create unpleasant odors that affect the quality of life for nearby residents.

The Kettleman Hills Landfill in California is notorious for odor issues secondary to organic wastes. It has raised health concerns from nearby residents, leading to complaints and community protests.

Efforts have been made to mitigate these issues. But the landfill’s history illustrates the challenges many waste management facilities face vis-à-vis odors and their impact on surrounding communities.

5. How can the benefits of municipal landfills be ensured and maximized?

Municipal landfills must be carefully monitored and managed to minimize environmental risks. Effective strategies include:

• Prevention of contamination—so that hazardous waste doesn’t enter landfills to contaminate soil and groundwater.
• Source reduction—such as cleaner production methods to reduce the overall volume that needs to be placed and managed in municipal landfills.
• Recycling & recovery—to conserve natural resources and consequently reduce the amount of waste sent to the landfill.
• Treatment technologies—to neutralize or stabilize hazardous wastes, making them less harmful before disposal.
• Separation & diversion—by segregating hazardous wastes at their source so that a significant portion can be managed by methods other than landfilling.
• Education & compliance­—to raise awareness about proper hazardous waste disposal, thus improving compliance with regulations and reducing illegal dumping.

6. Have questions about landfills?

As an industry leader in RCRA-compliant waste management, Hazardous Waste Experts can help you facilitate the responsible and ethical disposal and/or recycling of any waste—any place.

Do you have questions about any facet of waste management, including municipal landfills or hazardous waste treatment, storage, and/or disposal facilities?

Get expert advice now—or call us at our new telephone number: 425.414.3485.

And thank you for reading our blog!